Waterside restaurant deck with a set table and jetty, French side of St Martin

Choose St Barths for a small French island of villas, long beach lunches and a polished harbour town, and accept the prices that come with it. Choose St Martin for more space, more flights, two cultures and a wider range of budgets. The islands are about 25 km apart, so many trips include both.

Nearly every trip starts on St Martin anyway, because no long-haul flight lands on St Barths. We compare the two, say which one we would pick for which trip, and explain how to split a stay between them.

St Barths and St Martin at a glance

  • St Barths covers about 24 km². St Martin is nearly four times larger, at about 90 km², split between France in the north and the Netherlands in the south.
  • Long-haul flights land at Princess Juliana, on St Martin's Dutch side. St Barths is 45 minutes away by ferry, or 10 to 15 minutes by small plane.
  • St Barths and French St Martin use the euro. Dutch Sint Maarten mostly works in US dollars, which are accepted all over the island.
  • St Barths is quiet, groomed and very French. St Martin is bigger, busier and more mixed, with a calmer French north and a livelier Dutch south.
  • St Barths is expensive at every level. St Martin runs from simple apartments to Belmond La Samanna.
  • St Barths suits couples, families in villas and anyone who wants long lunches and little else. St Martin suits groups on mixed budgets, food lovers and travellers who want choice and late nights.

One French island, one shared island

St Barths was Swedish from 1784 to 1878, which is why its capital is called Gustavia, and it has been a French overseas collectivity since 2007. Nothing on the island is large. Eden Rock, the hotel on its rock above Saint-Jean, has 37 rooms, suites and villas, and much of the accommodation is in private villas rented by the week.

St Martin has been divided since the Treaty of Concordia of 1648, which the St Maarten Tourist Bureau describes as the oldest treaty still in force in the Caribbean. You drive from one side to the other without a border check, yet they feel different. The north is French, with the euro, European plugs on 220 volts and shops that close for lunch; the south is Sint Maarten, a country within the Kingdom of the Netherlands, with US plugs on 110 volts, the airport, the cruise port and the casinos.

Getting to St Martin and across to St Barths

Princess Juliana International Airport is the hub for the whole area, with Air France and KLM from Paris and Amsterdam and the main US airlines from their hubs. Every arriving passenger, including those only changing for another island, must complete Sint Maarten's digital entry form, which takes minutes online before you fly.

St Barths is a different matter. Its airport, on the bay of Saint-Jean, has a 650-metre runway, opens at 7am and shuts 15 minutes after sunset, between about 6pm and 7pm depending on the season, according to the St Barths tourism office. The hop is by small plane: St Barth Commuter and Winair cross from Princess Juliana in 10 to 15 minutes, and Tradewind Aviation flies in from San Juan and Antigua.

By sea, Great Bay Express sails from Bobby's Marina in Philipsburg and takes 45 minutes. Its 2026 timetable has departures at 7.15am (not on Sundays), 9.45am and 5.30pm, with boats back from Gustavia at 8.30am (not on Sundays), 11am and 6.45pm. Voyager sails from Marigot, on the French side, in about an hour.

The consequence is simple: if your long-haul flight lands after mid-afternoon, you can miss both the last boat and the last plane. Plan a night on St Martin and cross in the morning. Private jets also land at Princess Juliana, and the last leg is then a short helicopter or turboprop flight in daylight.

St Barths sits outside the Schengen area, so carry a passport and check the visa rules for your nationality. US, Canadian and British visitors need no visa for stays of up to 90 days.

Beaches, food and nights out

Beaches

St Barths' beaches are smaller and calmer. Shell Beach is a five-minute walk from Gustavia, and Saint-Jean, in front of Eden Rock and Nikki Beach, is the sociable one. Colombier can only be reached on foot or by boat, and Grand Cul-de-Sac is a sheltered lagoon for young children. For a long swim with fewer people, drive to Gouverneur or Grande Saline.

St Martin has more of everything: the St Maarten Tourist Bureau counts 37 beaches around the island. Orient Bay is the long beach-club strip of the French side, Baie Longue below La Samanna is long and quiet, and Maho is the beach under the flight path. Pinel, a small islet a short boat ride from Cul-de-Sac, is busy at lunchtime and empties after the last shuttle, at about 4.30pm.

Food

For the money, St Martin is the better food island, and Grand Case is the reason. Its main street mixes serious French cooking, such as Le Pressoir in an old Creole house, with the lolos, open-air grills by the water serving lobster, ribs and johnnycakes. Simpson Bay, on the Dutch side, is the other dining strip. For the big nights on both islands, from Super Island at Christmas to SXM Festival in March, see our party season guide.

St Barths eats on a different rhythm: the long lunch on the sand is the event of the day, and dinner starts late in Gustavia or Saint-Jean. Bonito, above Gustavia harbour, is the kind of dinner that runs into the night. This season has also brought several new names, covered in our guide to what is new in St Barths for 2026/27.

Nights out

Nightlife is where the islands differ most. St Barths goes out at dinner and at beach clubs such as Nikki Beach on Saint-Jean, and peaks over the week covered in our St Barths New Year's Eve guide. St Martin's Dutch side stays up later: its casinos, including Casino Royale in Maho Village and the Hollywood Casino at Pelican, open in the early afternoon and run into the small hours.

Hotels, villas and what to budget for

St Barths is a villa island with a short list of hotels, nearly all of them expensive. Eden Rock on Saint-Jean, Cheval Blanc St-Barth on Flamands and Le Sereno on Grand Cul-de-Sac, which reopens for the season on 16 November 2026, are the established names. Christmas and New Year are the most expensive weeks of the year, and villas often set minimum stays over the holidays.

St Martin covers every budget. At the top is Belmond La Samanna, above Baie Longue on the French side, with 74 rooms and suites and eight villas; it reopens for the season on 15 November 2026. Grand Case Beach Club, an all-suite hotel with two beaches at the quiet end of Grand Case bay, keeps the restaurants within walking distance. Below those sit apartments, guesthouses and villas at prices St Barths cannot match.

For six or more people, a villa with staff is usually better value than several rooms. We arrange villa rentals on St Barths and St Martin, and check the minimum stay, the staff and the payment schedule before any deposit.

Which island for which trip

  • For a couple on a first Caribbean trip, we would pick St Barths for a week, or two nights in Grand Case followed by five on St Barths.
  • A family with young children does well in a villa near Grand Cul-de-Sac on St Barths, for the calm water, or at La Samanna on St Martin.
  • Friends on mixed budgets are better on St Martin, in a villa on the French side, with nights out on the Dutch side.
  • Food lovers belong on St Martin, for Grand Case, with a day across the water for lunch on St Barths.
  • A milestone over Christmas or New Year means St Barths, booked months ahead.

Three mistakes come up again and again. People treat St Barths as an airport transfer and forget the separate passport check. They book a long-haul flight that lands after the last boat and plane. And they think of St Martin as one place, though its French north and Dutch south belong to two different countries, and it shows.

How to combine St Barths and St Martin

St Martin first, St Barths second is the order that works. Two or three nights in Grand Case or at La Samanna let you recover from the flight and eat well, then a morning boat or plane takes you across. Going home, leave St Barths in the morning with several hours in hand, as the weather can delay a crossing.

Day trips are easy in one direction. The 9.45am boat from Philipsburg reaches Gustavia at 10.30am, and the 6.45pm boat brings you back by 7.30pm, which leaves a full day for the harbour, Shell Beach and lunch. Our guide to the islands near St Martin covers that day, along with Anguilla, Saba and the others.

The other direction is harder. The last boat from Philipsburg leaves at 5.30pm and St Barths' airport closes at dusk, so a dinner in Grand Case from a villa on St Barths means a night on St Martin. Plan it as a one-night stopover, ideally on the way home.

Frequently asked questions

Is St Barths more expensive than St Martin?

Yes, by a wide margin. St Barths has small luxury hotels, villas and very few simple options, while St Martin has rooms at every level, up to Belmond La Samanna. The gap is widest over Christmas and New Year.

How do you get from St Martin to St Barths?

By ferry or by small plane. Great Bay Express takes 45 minutes from Philipsburg and Voyager about an hour from Marigot, while St Barth Commuter and Winair fly from Princess Juliana in 10 to 15 minutes. Carry your passport, which the ferry company requires for every passenger.

Which side of St Martin is better, French or Dutch?

For a quieter stay and the better restaurants, the French side, around Grand Case, Orient Bay and Baie Longue. For casinos, late bars and the shortest drive to the airport, the Dutch side. There is no border check between them, so many visitors sleep on one side and eat on the other.

When is the best time to visit St Barths and St Martin?

December to May, the dry season described by St Barths' tourism office, brings the most reliable weather and the highest prices. June to November is hotter and more humid, and many St Barths addresses close for part of the autumn. Christmas and New Year are the peak weeks and fill first.

Planning St Barths and St Martin with TG Hospitality

Tell us your dates, who is coming and the kind of days you want, and we will tell you plainly which island fits, or how to split the stay. We would then book the villa or hotel through our partners, the crossing from Princess Juliana by boat, plane or helicopter, and the tables worth planning around on both islands. You can see our other destinations on our locations page, and reach us through our contact page or on WhatsApp.

Recent posts
More guides from the team that makes the bookings.
19 Nov 2026
Travel Planning
photo
Wellness now travels with you, from Pilates on deck to padel at the villa

Private Pilates and Lagree, personal trainers, padel coaches, ski instructors and osteopaths who come to you: what our clients book now, and how to plan it.

photo
A concierge in Singapore, from race week to Chinese New Year

Marina Bay hotels and Raffles, a table at Odette, TOKEN2049 and the Grand Prix in the same October week, and Chinese New Year: what a concierge books in Singapore, and when.

photo
Where to eat during Circoloco Phuket 2027

The tables we book around Circoloco's three Saturdays on Natai, from PRU and Zuma's Sunday brunch to Nama, Bisou, Ta Khai and L'Arôme by the Sea, and how to time meals around a 3pm start.

19 Nov 2026
Travel Planning
photo
Wellness now travels with you, from Pilates on deck to padel at the villa

Private Pilates and Lagree, personal trainers, padel coaches, ski instructors and osteopaths who come to you: what our clients book now, and how to plan it.

photo
A concierge in Singapore, from race week to Chinese New Year

Marina Bay hotels and Raffles, a table at Odette, TOKEN2049 and the Grand Prix in the same October week, and Chinese New Year: what a concierge books in Singapore, and when.

Read all posts
Icon Arrow